Continue to love them all!
I ended up buying two more and now have three of these sweaters in different colors: olive, navy, and charcoal. The sweater is thick and keeps me warm with an undershirt and long sleeve shirt. I'm 5'4" and it hits me right around the hips. The sweater is shorter than most long sleeve shirts, so depending on the length of the shirt, it can be showing a little bit from the sweater or tucked in. The arms on this sweater are a bit long so I do end up cuffing them.
Love this sweater!
I bought the olive a while ago then bought two more because I am in love with them. The weight, cut, color choices, and length all work for me. I'm about 5'4" and usually purchase XS from Not Monday but I went for S because I do wear a base layer and another shirt under it. The sleeves are long, so I usually fold them over.